Bucketwise Sign in free

Learn / Portfolio

Collection efficiency: formula, types and the SQL to calculate it

Collection efficiency, or CE, tells you how much of what was due in a month the lender actually collected, usually as collections divided by amount due. It is quoted everywhere and defined differently almost everywhere, so the first job is to say which version you mean.

How is collection efficiency calculated?

There is no single standard definition. What counts as due and what counts as collected changes the answer, and a figure without its definition cannot be compared with anyone else's.

Which three versions of collection efficiency will you see?

VersionFormulaWhat it tells you
Current CECollected against this month's instalments / this month's instalments dueWhether customers are paying on time, month by month
Total CE(Collected on current + collected on overdue) / (current due + overdue brought forward)How much of the whole demand was recovered, including old arrears
Count-based CEAccounts that paid in full / accounts with an instalment dueHow many customers paid, whatever the amount

Current CE is the strictest on timeliness. Total CE is lower when there is a pile of old arrears, because that pile sits in the denominator. Count-based CE ignores ticket size, so a few large unpaid accounts hide inside it.

Worked example: collection efficiency for one month

Illustrative lender, one month, figures in crore
Current demand (instalments due this month)100
Overdue brought forward20
Collected against current demand91
Collected against overdue6
Current CE91 / 100 = 91.0%
Total CE(91 + 6) / (100 + 20) = 97 / 120 = 80.8%
Wrong mix: all collections over current demand97 / 100 = 97.0%

The last line is a common mistake. It puts arrears collected in the numerator and leaves arrears out of the denominator, so the ratio looks 6 points better than the current CE and 16 points better than the total CE.

Count-based CE needs account counts. If 8,700 of 10,000 accounts with an instalment due paid in full, it is 87%. Those numbers are made up.

Why does the way a payment is split matter?

When a customer pays less than total due, the lender decides how the payment is split between overdue and current. Oldest due first is common. Under that rule a part payment clears old arrears first, so current CE falls and total CE does not change. The allocation rule moves the split, never the total. State your rule next to the number.

What data do you need?

ColumnWhat it holdsWatch out
loan_idThe loanOne row per loan per month
month_endThe month being measuredUse the last day of the month
current_demandInstalments falling due in the monthNot the full outstanding balance
overdue_bfUnpaid amount brought forward at the start of the monthZero for loans that were current
coll_currentCollected against the current demandDepends on your allocation rule
coll_overdueCollected against overdueDepends on your allocation rule

If your system stores only payments, build this table first. The data guide and the derived fields guide show how to get demand and overdue from the schedule and the payments.

How do you calculate collection efficiency in SQL?

One row per month with current CE, total CE and the share of accounts that paid their current demand in full. We ran this on sample data and checked every number against a separate calculation.

SELECT month_end,
       100.0 * SUM(coll_current) / SUM(current_demand)            AS current_ce_pct,
       100.0 * SUM(coll_current + coll_overdue)
             / SUM(current_demand + overdue_bf)                   AS total_ce_pct,
       100.0 * SUM(CASE WHEN coll_current >= current_demand THEN 1 ELSE 0 END)
             / COUNT(*)                                           AS paid_in_full_pct
FROM   demand_collection
GROUP  BY month_end
ORDER  BY month_end;

The query uses standard SQL (SUM, CASE, GROUP BY). Replace the table and column names with yours. Only the current-CE line and the paid-in-full line depend on your allocation rule.

What should you check before you publish the number?

Why read collection efficiency next to DPD, not instead of it?

A CE of 95% can sit beside a worsening book. The 5% that is not collected may be the same customers each month, rolling from bucket to bucket. Put CE beside the bucket table and the roll rate matrix. CE tells you how much came in. Roll rates tell you who is slipping.

Try it on your own tables

The free tools give you the prompt, the checks and how to present the result. You enter table names only.

See the free tools

Frequently asked questions

What is the collection efficiency formula?

Amount collected divided by amount due, times 100. Say whether the amount due is only this month's instalments or also includes overdue brought forward.

Can collection efficiency be more than 100%?

Yes. Prepayments, advance instalments and recoveries of old arrears can push collections above the current demand. Show them separately so the figure still means something.

What is the difference between current CE and total CE?

Current CE measures collections against this month's instalments only. Total CE includes overdue brought forward in both the amount collected and the amount due, so it is usually lower when there are old arrears.

What is a good collection efficiency?

It depends on the product, the customer segment and the lender. Compare a lender with its own earlier months, using the same definition.

Keep reading